= Upgrading from v2 to v3

The configuration for 3.0 is *largely* compatible with the 2.x.x
configuration.  However, it is NOT possible to simply use the 2.x.x
configuration as-is.  Instead, you should re-create it.

== Security

A number of configuration items have moved into the "security" subsection of
radiusd.conf.  If you use these, you should move them. Otherwise, they can
be ignored.

The list of moved options is:

* chroot
* user
* group
* allow_core_dumps
* reject_delay
* status_server

These entries should be moved from "radiusd.conf" to the "security"
subsection of that file.

== Naming

Many names used by configuration items were inconsistent in earlier
versions of the server.  These names have been unified in version 3.0.

If a file is being referenced or created the config item `filename`
is used.

If a file is being created, the initial permissions are set by the
`permissions` config item.

If a directory hierarchy needs to be created, the permissions are set
by `dir_permissions`.

If an external host is referenced in the context of a module the
`server` config item is used.

Unless the config item is a well recognised portmanteau
(as `filename` is for example), it must be written as multiple
distinct words separated by underscores `_`.

The configuration items `file`, `script_file`, `module`,
`detail`, `detailfile`, `attrsfile`, `perm`, `dirperm`,
`detailperm`, and `hostname` are deprecated. As well as any false
portmanteaus, and configuration items that used hyphens as word
delimiters.  e.g. `foo-bar` has been changed to `foo_bar`.  Please
update your module configuration to use the new syntax.

In most cases the server will tell you the replacement config item to
use.  As always, run the server in debugging mode to see these
messages.

== Modules Directory

As of version 3.0, the `modules/` directory no longer exists.

Instead, all "example" modules have been put into the
`mods-available/` directory.  Modules which can be loaded by the
server are placed in the `mods-enabled/` directory.  All of the
modules in that directory will be loaded.  This means that the
`instantiate` section of radiusd.conf is less important.  The only
reason to list a module in the `instantiate` section is to force
ordering when the modules are loaded. 

Modules can be enabled by creating a soft link.  For module `foo`, do:

[source,shell]
----
cd raddb/mods-enabled
ln -s ../mods-available/foo
----

To create "local" versions of the modules, we suggest copying the file
instead.  This leaves the original file (with documentation) in the
`mods-available/` directory.  Local changes should go into the
`mods-enabled/` directory.

Module-specific configuration files are now in the `mods-config/`
directory.  This change allows for better organization, and means that
there are fewer files in the main `raddb` directory.  See
`mods-config/README.rst` for more details.

== Changed Modules

The following modules have been changed in this version.

=== rlm_sql

The SQL configuration has been moved from `sql.conf` to
`mods-available/sql`.  The `sqlippool.conf` file has also been
moved to `mods-available/sqlippool`.

The SQL module configuration has been changed.  The old connection
pool options are no longer accepted:

----
num_sql_socks
connect_failure_retry_delay
lifetime
max_queries
----

Instead, a connection pool configuration is used.  This configuration
contains all of the functionality of the previous configuration, but
in a more generic form.  It also is used in multiple modules, meaning
that there are fewer different configuration items.  The mapping
between the configuration items is:

----
num_sql_socks			-> pool { max }
connect_failure_retry_delay	-> pool { retry_delay }
lifetime			-> pool { lifetime }
max_queries			-> pool { uses }
----

The pool configuration adds a number of new configuration options,
which allow the administrator to better control how FreeRADIUS uses
SQL connection pools.

The following parameters have been changed:

----
trace				-> removed
tracefile			-> logfile
----

The logfile is intended to log SQL queries performed.  If you need to
debug the server, use debugging mode.  If `logfile` is set, then
*all* SQL queries will go to `logfile`.

You can now use a NULL SQL database:

.Example
----
driver = rlm_sql_null
----

This is an empty driver which will always return "success".  It is
intended to be used to replace the `sql_log` module, and to work in
conjunction with the `radsqlrelay` program.  Simply take your normal
configuration for raddb/mods-enabled/sql, and set:

.Example
----
driver = rlm_sql_null
...
logfile = ${radacctdir}/sql.log
----

All of the SQL queries will be logged to that file.  The connection
pool does not need to be configured for the `null` SQL driver.  It
can be left as-is, or deleted from the SQL configuration file.


=== rlm_sql_sybase

The `rlm_sql_sybase` module has been renamed to `rlm_sql_freetds`
and the old `rlm_sql_freetds` module has been removed.

`rlm_sql_sybase` used the newer ct-lib API, and `rlm_sql_freetds`
used an older API and was incomplete.

The new `rlm_sql_freetds` module now also supports database
selection on connection startup so `use` statements no longer
have to be included in queries.


=== sql/dialup.conf

Queries for post-auth and accounting calls have been re-arranged.  The
SQL module will now expand the 'reference' configuration item in the
appropriate sub-section, and resolve this to a configuration
item. This behaviour is similar to rlm_linelog.  This dynamic
expansion allows for a dynamic mapping between accounting types and
SQL queries.  Previously, the mapping was fixed.  Any "new" accounting
type was ignored by the module.  Now, support for any accounting type
can be added by just adding a new target, as below.

Queries from v2.x.x may be manually copied to the new v3.0
`dialup.conf` file (`raddb/sql/main/<dialect>/queries.conf`).
When doing this you may also need to update references to the
accounting tables, as their definitions will now be outside of
the subsection containing the query.

The mapping from old "fixed" query to new "dynamic" query is as follows:

----
accounting_onoff_query		-> accounting.type.accounting-on.query
accounting_update_query		-> accounting.type.interim-update.query
accounting_update_query_alt	+> accounting.type.interim-update.query
accounting_start_query		-> accounting.type.start.query
accounting_start_query_alt	+> accounting.type.start.query
accounting_stop_query		-> accounting.type.stop.query
accounting_stop_query_alt	+> accounting.type.stop.query
postauth_query			-> post-auth.query
----

Alternatively a 2.x.x config may be patched to work with the
3.0 module by adding the following:

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
 accounting {
  	reference = "%{tolower:type.%{Acct-Status-Type}.query}"
		type {
			accounting-on {
				query = "${....accounting_onoff_query}"
			}
			accounting-off {
				query = "${....accounting_onoff_query}"
			}
			start {
				query = "${....accounting_start_query}"
				query = "${....accounting_start_query_alt}"
			}
			interim-update {
				query = "${....accounting_update_query}"
				query = "${....accounting_update_query_alt}"
			}
			stop {
				query = "${....accounting_stop_query}"
				query = "${....accounting_stop_query_alt}"
			}
		}
  }
  post-auth {
	query = "${..postauth_query}"
  }
----

In general, it is safer to migrate the configuration rather than
trying to "patch" it, to make it look like a v2 configuration.

Note that the sub-sections holding the queries are labelled
`accounting-on`, and not `accounting_on`.  The reason is that the
names of these sections are taken directly from the
`Accounting-Request` packet, and the `Acct-Status-Type` field.
The `sql` module looks at the value of that field, and then looks
for a section of that name, in order to find the query to use.

That process means that the server can be extended to support any new
value of `Acct-Status-Type`, simply by adding a named sub-section,
and a query.  This behavior is preferable to that of v2, which had
hard-coded queries for certain `Acct-Status-Type` values, and was
ignored all other values.

=== rlm_ldap

The LDAP module configuration has been substantially changed.  Please
read `raddb/mods-available/ldap`.  It now uses a connection pool,
just like the SQL module.

Many of the configuration items remain the same, but they have been
moved into subsections.  This change is largely cosmetic, but it makes
the configuration clearer.  Instead of having a large set of random
configuration items, they are now organized into logical groups.

You will need to read your old LDAP configuration, and migrate it
manually to the new configuration.  Simply copying the old
configuration WILL NOT WORK.

Users upgrading from 2.x.x who used to call the ldap module in
`post-auth` should now set `edir_autz = yes`, and remove the `ldap`
module from the `post-auth` section.

=== rlm_ldap and LDAP-Group

In 2.x.x the registration of the `LDAP-Group` pair comparison was done
by the last instance of rlm_ldap to be instantiated. In 3.0 this has
changed so that only the default `ldap {}` instance registers
`LDAP-Group`.

If `<instance>-LDAP-Group` is already used throughout your configuration
no changes will be needed.

=== rlm_ldap authentication

In 2.x.x the LDAP module had a `set_auth_type` configuration item,
which forced `Auth-Type := ldap`. This was removed in 3.x.x as it
often did not work, and was not consistent with the rest of the
server.  We generally recommend that LDAP should be used as a
database, and that FreeRADIUS should do authentication.

The only reason to use `Auth-Type := ldap` is when the LDAP server
will not supply the "known good" password to FreeRADIUS, *and* where
the Access-Request contains User-Password.  This situation happens
only for Active Directory.  If you think you need to force `Auth-Type
:= ldap` in other situations, you are very likely to be wrong.

The following is an example of what should be inserted into the
`authorize {}` and `authenticate {}` sections of the relevant
virtual-servers, to get functionality equivalent to v2.x:

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
authorize {
	...
	ldap
	if ((ok || updated) && User-Password) {
		update control {
	Auth-Type := ldap
	}
...
}
authenticate {
	...
	Auth-Type ldap {
		ldap
	}
...
}
----

=== rlm_eap

The EAP configuration has been moved from `eap.conf` to
`mods-available/eap`.  A new `pwd` subsection has been added for
EAP-PWD.


=== rlm_expiration & rlm_logintime

The rlm_expiration and rlm_logintime modules no longer add a `Reply-Message`,
the same behaviour can be achieved checking the return code of the module and
adding the `Reply-Message` with unlang:

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
expiration
if (userlock) {
	update reply {
		Reply-Message := "Your account has expired"
	}
}
----
  
  
=== rlm_unix

The `unix` module does not have an `authenticate` section.  So you
cannot set `Auth-Type := System`.  The `unix` module has also been
deleted from the examples in `sites-available/`.  Listing it there
has been deprecated for many years.

The PAP module can do crypt authentication.  It should be used instead
of Unix authentication.

The Unix module still can pull the passwords from `/etc/passwd`, or
`/etc/shadow`.  This is done by listing it in the `authorize`
section, as is done in the examples in `sites-available/`.  However,
some systems using NIS or NSS will not supply passwords to the
`unix` module.  For those systems, we recommend putting users and
passwords into a database, instead of relying on `/etc/passwd`.


=== rlm_preprocess

In 2.x.x `huntroups` and `users` files were loaded from default locations
without being configured explicitly. Since 3.x.x you need to set
`huntgroups` and `users` configuration item(s) in module section in order
to get them being processed.


== New Modules

=== rlm_date

Instances of rlm_date register an xlat method which can translate
integer and date values to an arbitrarily formatted date time
string, or an arbitrarily formated time string to an integer, 
depending on the attribute type passed.


=== rlm_rest

The `rest` module is used to translate RADIUS requests into 
RESTfull HTTP requests. Currently supported body types are JSON
and POST.


=== rlm_unpack

The `unpack` module is used to turn data buried inside of binary
attributes.  e.g. if we have `Class = 0x00000001020304` then:

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
Tmp-Integer-0 := "%{unpack:&Class 4 short}"
----

will unpack octets 4 and 5 as a "short", which has value 0x0304.
All integers are assumed to be in network byte order.


=== rlm_yubikey

The `yubikey` module can be used to forward yubikey OTP token
values to a Yubico validation server, or decrypt the token 
using a PSK.


== Deleted Modules
 
The following modules have been deleted, and are no longer supported
in Version 3.  If you are using one of these modules, your
configuration can probably be changed to not need it.  Otherwise email
the freeradius-devel list, and ask about the module.


=== rlm_acct_unique

This module has been replaced by the "acct_unique" policy.  See
raddb/policy.d/accounting.

The method for calculating the value of acct_unique has changed.
However, as this method was configurable, this change should not
matter.  The only issue is in having a v2 and v3 server writing to the
same database at the same time.  They will calculate different values
for Acct-Unique-Id.


=== rlm_acctlog

You should use rlm_linelog instead.  That module has a superset of the
acctlog functionality.


=== rlm_attr_rewrite

The attr_rewrite module looked for an attribute, and then re-wrote it,
or created a new attribute.  All of that can be done in "unlang".

A sample configuration in "unlang" is:

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
if (request:Calling-Station-Id) {
  update request {
    Calling-Station-Id := "...."
  }
}
----

We suggest updating all uses of attr_rewrite to use unlang instead.


=== rlm_checkval

The checkval module compared two attributes.  All of that can be done in "unlang":

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
if (&request:Calling-Station-Id == &control:Calling-Station-Id) {
  ok
}
----

We suggest updating all uses of checkval to use unlang instead.


=== rlm_dbm

No one seems to use it.  There is no sample configuration for it.
There is no speed advantage to using it over the "files" module.
Modern systems are fast enough that 10K entries can be read from the
"users" file in about 10ms.  If you need more users than that, use a
real database such as SQL.


=== rlm_fastusers

No one seems to use it.  It has been deprecated since Version 2.0.0.
The "files" module was rewritten so that the "fastusers" module was no
longer necessary.


=== rlm_policy

No one seems to use it.  Almost all of its functionality is available
via `unlang`.


=== rlm_sim_files

The rlm_sim_files module has been deleted.  It was never marked "stable",
and was never used in a production environment.  There are better ways
to test EAP.

If you want similar functionality, see rlm_passwd.  It can read CSV
files, and create attributes from them.


=== rlm_sql_log

This has been replaced with the "null" sql driver.  See
`raddb/mods-available/sql` for an example configuration.

The main SQL module has more functionality than rlm_sql_log, and
results in less code in the server.

== Other Functionality

The following is a list of new / changed functionality.

=== RadSec

RadSec (or RADIUS over TLS) is now supported.  RADIUS over bare TCP
is also supported, but is recommended only for secure networks.

See `sites-available/tls` for complete details on using TLS.  The server
can both receive incoming TLS connections, and also originate outgoing
TLS connections.

The TLS configuration is taken from the old EAP-TLS configuration.  It
is largely identical to the old EAP-TLS configuration, so it should be
simple to use and configure.  It re-uses much of the EAP-TLS code,
so it is well-tested and reliable.

Once RadSec is enabled, normal debugging mode will not work.  This is
because the TLS code requires threading to work properly.  Instead of doing:

.Example
[source,shell]
----
radiusd -X
----

you will need to do:

.Example
[source,shell]
----
radiusd -fxx -l stdout
----

That's the price to pay for using RadSec.  This limitation may be
lifted in a future version of the server.


=== PAP and User-Password

From version 3.0 onwards the server no longer supports authenticating
against a cleartext password in the 'User-Password' attribute. Any
occurences of this (for instance, in the users file) should now be changed
to 'Cleartext-Password' instead.

e.g. change entries like this:

----
bob User-Password == "hello"
----

to ones like this:

----
bob Cleartext-Password := "hello"
----

If this is not done, authentication will likely fail.  The server will
also print a helpful message in debugging mode.

If it really is impossible to do this, the following unlang inserted above
the call to the pap module may be used to copy User-Password to the correct
attribute:

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
if (!control:Cleartext-Password && control:User-Password) {
  update control {
    Cleartext-Password := "%{control:User-Password}"
  }
}
----

However, this should only be seen as a temporary, not permanent, fix.
It is better to fix your databases to use the correct configuration.


== Unlang


The unlang policy language is compatible with v2, but has a number of
new features.  See `man unlang` for complete documentation.


=== Errors

Many more errors are caught when the server is starting up.  Syntax
errors in `unlang` are caught, and a helpful error message is
printed.  The error message points to the exact place where the error
occurred:

----
  ./raddb/sites-enabled/default[230]: Parse error in condition
  ERROR:  if (User-Name ! "bob") {
  ERROR:                ^ Invalid operator
----

`update` sections are more generic.  Instead of doing `update
reply`, you can do the following:

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
update {
	  reply:Class := 0x0000
	  control:Cleartext-Password := "hello"
}
----

This change means that you need fewer `update` sections.


=== Comparisons

Attribute comparisons can be done via the `&` operator.  When you
needed to compare two attributes, the old comparison style was:

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
if (User-Name == "%{control:Tmp-String-0}") {
----

This syntax is inefficient, as the `Tmp-String-0` attribute would be
printed to an intermediate string, causing unnecessary work.  You can
now instead compare the two attributes directly:

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
if (&User-Name == &control:Tmp-String-0) {
----

See `man unlang` for more details.

=== Casts

Casts are now permitted.  This allows you to force type-specific
comparisons:

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
if (<ipaddr>"%{sql: SELECT...}" == 127.0.0.1) {
----

This forces the string returned by the SELECT to be treated as an IP
address, and compare to `127.0.0.1`.  Previously, the comparison
would have been done as a simple string comparison.


=== Networks

IP networks are now supported:

  if (127.0.0.1/32 == 127.0.0.1) {

Will be `true`.  The various comparison operators can be used to
check IP network membership::

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
if (127/8 > 127.0.0.1) {
----

Returns `true`, because `127.0.0.1` is within the `127/8`
network.  However, the following comparison will return `false`::

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
if (127/8 > 192.168.0.1) {
----

because `192.168.0.1` is outside of the `127/8` network.


=== Optimization

As `unlang` is now pre-compiled, many compile-time optimizations are
done.  This means that the debug output may not be exactly the same as
what is in the configuration files:

  if (0 && (User-Name == "bob')) {

The result will always be `false`, as the `if 0` prevents the
following `&& ...` from being evaluated.

Not only that, but the entire contents of that section will be ignored
entirely:

.Example
[source,unlang]
----
if (0) {
    this_module_does_not_exist
    and_this_one_does_not_exist_either
}
----

In v2, that configuration would result in a parse error, as there is
no module called `this_module_does_not_exist`.  In v3, that text is
ignored.  This ability allows you to have dynamic configurations where
certain parts are used (or not) depending on compile-time configuration.

Similarly, conditions which always evaluate to `true` will be
optimized away:


.Example
[source,unlang]
----
if (1) {
    files
}
----

That configuration will never show the `if (1)` output in debugging mode.

=== Dialup_admin

The dialup_admin directory has been removed.  No one stepped forward
to maintain it, and the code had not been changed in many years.

